Judicial Evaluations: 12th Circuit

Including: Will county.

More information about ISBA Ratings and Judicial Advisory Polls.

Twelfth Judicial Circuit (Joint Poll with Will County Bar Association)

Judicial Advisory Polls

Note: Opinions expressed are of those lawyers who chose to respond and not of the Illinois State Bar Association. Percentage is based on "yes" responses to each question; "no opinion" responses are not included.

Ballots mailed - 922 Ballots returned - 277

	Recommended/ Not Recommended	Meets Require- ments of Office	Integrity	Impar- tiality	Legal Ability	Tempera- ment	Court Manage- ment	Health	Sensi- tivity
Jeff Allen	Recommended	79.71	88.41	79.90	79.51	90.82	89.71	97.56	93.69
Elizabeth Dow	Recommended	84.68	96.40	94.50	85.19	95.50	91.67	98.20	96.36
Derek W. Ewanic	Recommended	71.43	97.14	79.41	60.00	91.43	82.86	100.00	85.71
Paula A. Gomora	Not- Recommended	51.27	76.13	67.31	57.96	82.05	79.87	96.08	83.97
Sarah Jones	Not- Recommended	53.90	79.43	55.07	65.71	51.06	78.17	89.36	77.30
Ray Nash	Recommended	95.08	97.33	95.14	93.01	97.28	96.22	99.46	97.31

For Retention

Joint Poll with Will County Bar Association, Black Bar Association of Will County, and Will County Women’s Bar Association

Ballots mailed - 1295 Ballots returned - 327

	Recommended/ Not Recommended	Meets Require- ments of Office	Integrity	Impar- tiality	Legal Ability	Tempera- ment	Court Manage- ment	Health	Sensi- tivity
Amy M. Bertani-Tomczak	Recommended	84.16	89.35	87.04	86.11	89.40	87.10	97.66	93.06
Gerald R. Kinney	Recommended	95.36	97.01	95.28	97.44	97.87	97.45	99.57	97.45
Susan T. O’Leary	Recommended	84.74	93.65	89.42	82.11	89.36	92.02	96.79	94.09
Carla Alessio Policandriotes	Recommended	87.57	89.01	85.71	90.11	89.94	95.56	97.78	91.16
Richard C. Schoenstedt	Recommended	90.45	94.39	89.29	89.34	93.85	95.41	97.95	95.90
Dick Siegel	Recommended	75.00	87.57	84.09	75.43	77.59	86.86	93.60	89.66
Stephen D. White	Recommended	88.94	92.75	87.25	91.26	92.12	91.71	96.53	88.73