People v. Flemming

Defendant was convicted, after bench trial, of second degree murder and aggravated battery. A rational trier of fact could find evidence supports finding that Defendant's belief that circumstances justified using self-defense against stabbing victim was unreasonable. Thus, State proved first degree murder and disproved self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt. Rational trier of fact could find that other stabbing victim suffered great bodily harm, as victim testified that his injuries were severe enough to warrant medical treatment; and evidence supports finding that Defendant committed battery with a deadly weapon (knife) and thus is guilty of aggravated battery. Defense counsel's failure to present information as to victim's previous aggressiveness and criminal history was a legitimate trial strategy. (McBRIDE and TAYLOR, concurring.)